Symmetry and patterns
Symmetry mirrors a scene on either side of an axis, while a pattern repeats one element at regular intervals. Both create visual order.
Also known as: symmetrical composition, repeating patterns
Symmetry and patterns are compositional tools that create visual order: symmetry repeats the scene on either side of an axis, and a pattern repeats the same element at regular intervals. The eye recognizes them almost instantly, which is why the slightest deviation (a horizon at 1° or a piece out of place) stands out before any other flaw.
Symmetry needs a clean axis; a pattern needs an exception that gives it a point of interest.
Both tools ask for the opposite of the rule of thirds: center the subject. A frontal facade or a perfect reflection falls apart if you move the subject to a third, because what you are photographing is precisely the balance.
What settings does symmetry need?
Alignment before exposure. The camera has to be perpendicular to the plane you are photographing and level on both axes; the electronic level and the viewfinder grid do more for these photos than any aperture.
Scene: Reflection in a calm lake; Focal length (full frame): 24-35 mm; Aperture: f/11; Camera position: As low as possible, close to the water; What to watch: Remove the polarizer: it erases the reflection
Scene: Frontal facade; Focal length (full frame): 35-50 mm; Aperture: f/8; Camera position: Perpendicular, centered, level at 0°; What to watch: Barrel distortion at the edges
Scene: Tunnel or corridor; Focal length (full frame): 16-24 mm; Aperture: f/8; Camera position: On the central axis, at mid height; What to watch: Converging verticals
Scene: Repeated windows on a building; Focal length (full frame): 70-135 mm; Aperture: f/8; Camera position: Parallel to the plane of the facade; What to watch: That the repetition does not distort
The focal lengths are for a full-frame sensor. With a facade in full sun, ISO 100 and f/8 land at 1/400 s: f/8 lets in two stops more light than the f/16 of the Sunny 16 reference (1/100 s), which is why the shutter speed is two stops shorter. The cost of f/8 versus f/11 is less focus margin if the facade is not completely parallel to the sensor.
The polarizing filter deserves a separate note: on a mirror-like reflection in water, turning the polarizer removes exactly what you came to photograph. Take it off, or turn it to its position of minimum effect.
Where do I place the break in the pattern?
Away from the geometric center. A pattern with the exception right in the middle reads as a diagram; with the exception at a third, the eye first travels along the repetition and only then reaches the different element, which is the order that makes it work.
Also leave at least two complete repetitions on each side of the break. With fewer, the pattern does not get established and the exception does not read as an exception.
Common mistakes
Leveling by eye. A reflection with the horizon at 1° looks crooked even if it seems right on screen. Turn on the electronic level and shoot on a tripod if the light allows.
Framing the pattern with irregularly cut edges. If half a row shows at the top and a whole row at the bottom, the rhythm breaks where you did not want it to. Decide where the frame cuts just as you decide where the subject goes.
Using a very short wide angle and centering poorly. At 16 mm, a centimeter of off-center visibly changes the perspective of the two halves, and no software correction leaves it the same.
Trusting the reflection in wind. Gentle gusts are enough to undo the symmetry of the water. Wait for the calm of dawn or use a long exposure that averages out the ripples.
What to check before shooting
Three things, in this order: level at 0°, camera perpendicular to the plane, and an element that justifies the framing (the break in the pattern or the point where the symmetry closes). To work on it alongside the other tools, see the guide to dynamic visual composition, the article reflections in lakes: mirror composition and the lines and proportion part of architecture and panoramas.