Vibrance vs. saturation
Saturation boosts every color equally, while vibrance mainly lifts muted colors and protects skin tones. They look alike but behave very differently.
Also known as: vibrance and saturation, color intensity
Saturation and vibrance are two color intensity controls that look the same and are not: saturation raises all colors in the same proportion, whereas vibrance mainly raises the muted ones and leaves the ones that are already intense almost untouched, with extra protection for skin tones.
At the same value, saturation pushes the three colors equally and vibrance only lifts the one that was muted.
The saturation slider multiplies the intensity of every colored pixel without looking at where it starts. That is why a red that was already near the maximum leaves the color space and loses detail: it is clipping in one channel, and in the image it looks like a flat patch with no texture. Vibrance applies a curve: a lot of adjustment at the bottom, almost none at the top.
Which do I raise first and how far?
Vibrance is the main control and saturation the final touch-up. In Lightroom and Camera Raw both sliders run from −100 to +100, and in the Spanish interface vibrance is labeled "Intensidad."
Control: Vibrance; Usual range: +10 to +25; What it affects: Colors below 50% saturation; When to use it: General adjustment of almost any photo
Control: Vibrance; Usual range: +30 to +50; What it affects: The same, with an already visible effect; When to use it: Gray days, fog, washed-out scenes
Control: Saturation; Usual range: −5 to +5; What it affects: All colors equally; When to use it: Fine correction after vibrance
Control: Saturation; Usual range: −15 to −40; What it affects: All colors equally; When to use it: Lowering color: toned looks, partial black and white
Control: Saturation; Usual range: +20 or more; What it affects: All colors equally; When to use it: Almost never: it clips colors that are already intense
A starting point that works for landscapes with a muted sky: vibrance +20, saturation 0, and then lower the specific orange in the HSL panel if the ground has shifted in hue. Changing an individual color with color curves or with the HSL panel always gives more control than raising the global slider.
What happens with skin tones?
Skin tones are concentrated in a narrow band of oranges and reds of medium saturation. Saturation pushes them toward intense orange and the face comes to look spray-tanned; vibrance holds them back on purpose, which is why in portraits the difference between the two controls is the most visible of all.
With a person in the frame, the practical rule is not to touch global saturation in the positive direction. If the skin needs more color, raise it in the HSL panel only in the orange, and by 5 to 10 points, not 30.
Common mistakes
Raising saturation to fix a photo without contrast. What is missing is tonal contrast, not color. Raise blacks and whites first; often the color shows up on its own.
Finishing off a preset that already has color added. If the starting profile is already an intense color profile, vibrance adds to what is already there. Check the starting point before moving anything.
Not looking at the clipping warning. A raw converter's histogram marks clipping per channel. A saturated red can be blown out while the overall luminosity looks right.
Exporting to sRGB after saturating in ProPhoto. Colors that fit in the large space get squashed on conversion and flat patches appear where there used to be a gradient. Check the result in the output space, not the working space.
How to check it on your own photo
Duplicate the image, raise saturation +40 on one copy and vibrance +40 on the other, and look only at the skin and the sky. The difference shows in two seconds and you never forget it. To fit it into an orderly editing workflow, see the guide to post-processing: creative digital development and the applied workflow in landscape editing: complete Lightroom workflow.