High key and low key
High key and low key are two opposite lighting styles: one bright and airy with minimal shadows, the other dark and dramatic.
Also known as: high-key lighting, low-key lighting
High key and low key are two opposite lighting styles. High key produces predominantly bright images, with light tones and minimal shadows, conveying lightness, cleanliness and optimism; it's common in beauty, product and commercial portrait photography. Low key produces predominantly dark images, with selective highlights emerging from a shadowy background, conveying drama, mystery or intensity.
The difference isn't in the subject's exposure: it's in how much fill there is and what level the background is left at.
Neither is "correct": they are deliberate aesthetic decisions achieved by controlling the relationship between main light, fill and background, not simply by overexposing or underexposing.
What changes between one setup and the other?
The subject is exposed the same in both cases. What moves is the ratio between the main light and the fill, and the level of the background relative to the subject.
Parameter: Main : fill ratio; High key: 1:1 (no difference); Low key: 8:1 (3 stops) or no fill
Parameter: Background relative to the subject; High key: +1.5 to +2 EV; Low key: −3 EV or off
Parameter: Modifier; High key: Large softbox up close, or two; Low key: Grid, snoot or narrow softbox
Parameter: Wardrobe and set; High key: Whites and light grays; Low key: Blacks and light-absorbing fabrics
Parameter: Compensation in matrix metering; High key: +1 to +2 EV; Low key: −1 to −2 EV
Parameter: Histogram; High key: Mass in the right third, not touching the edge; Low key: Mass in the left third, not touching the edge
The +2 EV of the background in high key is the number that does the work: below +1.5 EV the white comes out gray, and above +2.5 EV the light bounces back toward the lens and washes the subject's outline with veiling flare.
How do I set up a high key shot?
With studio flash, f/8, 1/160 s, ISO 100 on full frame, two lights on the background metered two stops above the reading on the face, and the main and fill balanced on either side of the camera. A white reflector under the chin closes the remaining shadows.
With natural light it works the same without equipment: overcast day, subject in front of a white wall two meters behind, white reflector in front, f/2.8, 1/500 s, ISO 200 and +1 EV compensation. The overcast sky acts as a softbox several meters wide and the wall returns the fill.
And a low key shot?
A single light with a grid at 45° or 90°, no fill, and everything else black or far away. The background goes dark through distance: if you separate the subject three meters from the background, the light reaching it falls several stops by the inverse square law and the black comes out on its own, with no need for fabric.
With natural light, a single side window and the rest of the room in dim light give the same result: f/2, 1/125 s, ISO 800 with the subject two meters from the glass and a black card on the opposite side to kill the bounce from the walls.
Common mistakes
Believing high key means overexposing. A high key image keeps texture in skin, fabric and hair; an overexposed photo has those areas in pure white and there's no file underneath. Check with the highlight warning: the background may blink, the skin shouldn't.
Leaving low key without blacks. If the darkest point in the image is mid-gray, the photo looks dirty rather than dramatic. It needs a true black somewhere, even a small one.
Lighting the white background from the same place as the subject. The veil that appears at the edges comes from there. Light the background with its own lights, aimed at the background and not the subject, and separate it by two meters.
For starting setups and the role of fill, see the guide to studio lighting, the term fill light and the article Rembrandt, butterfly and side light: basic setups.