Fill light
Fill light is a secondary source, weaker than the main light, that brightens the shadows it casts and lowers the subject's contrast without erasing volume.
Also known as: fill
Fill light is a secondary light source, less intense than the main light, whose job is to brighten the shadows the main light casts and lower the subject's contrast without erasing volume. The difference in intensity between the two, measured in stops of light, is what decides whether the portrait comes out soft or dramatic.
The fill goes on the side opposite the key light; its relative intensity decides how much detail is left in the shadow.
The ratio is measured between the lit side and the shadow side of the face, and it is expressed in stops: 2:1 is a one-stop difference, 4:1 is two, 8:1 is three. Each additional stop halves the light reaching the shadow.
Which ratio should I use for each type of portrait?
Ratio: 1:1; Difference: 0 stops; Shadow look: No visible shadow, flat face; Where it fits: Very clean beauty, product on a white background
Ratio: 2:1; Difference: 1 stop; Shadow look: Volume barely hinted at; Where it fits: Corporate, weddings, professional profile photos
Ratio: 4:1; Difference: 2 stops; Shadow look: Strong volume, with detail; Where it fits: Editorial portrait, classic Rembrandt lighting
Ratio: 8:1; Difference: 3 stops; Shadow look: Shadow almost closed; Where it fits: Low key, dramatic portrait
Ratio: No fill; Difference: 4 stops or more; Shadow look: Black with no recoverable detail; Where it fits: Deliberate silhouettes and backlighting
Above 8:1, the RAW file no longer has usable information in the shadow: lifting that area in editing only brings out noise. If you want that look, make it a decision, not an accident. The same logic of extreme contrast is behind high key and low key.
What fill can I use if I don't have a second flash?
A reflector, a light-colored wall or the flash itself at low power. The physics is the same in all three cases and follows the inverse-square law: moving the reflector from 2 m to 1 m multiplies the light it returns by four, which is two more stops of fill without touching any setting.
Outdoors in full sun, a hot-shoe flash as fill works from a simple baseline: ISO 100, f/11 and 1/200 s (one stop more open than the Sunny 16 reference of f/16 at 1/100 s, to compensate for the sync speed) and flash compensation between −1 and −2 EV. With those values the background is exposed by the ambient light and the flash only lifts the eye sockets and the shadow under the chin. If the flash is noticeable, lower it another third of a stop before changing anything else.
A large softbox at half power fills more softly than a silver reflector, because the source is larger relative to the subject and the transition between light and shadow gets longer.
Common mistakes
Putting the fill at the same height and power as the key light. It leaves two crossed shadows under the nose and removes all volume. The fill goes lower, wider and always below the key in intensity.
Filling with a colored surface. A green wall or a red umbrella tints the shadow, and that color shift shows up only in the skin, which is where it is hardest to correct.
Confusing fill with lifting shadows in editing. Raising the shadows in the editor also raises the noise and flattens local contrast. Fill at capture puts in real light and keeps the texture.
Judging by eye on the screen. The screen's brightness fools you in the sun. Measure with a light meter or compare the two areas on the histogram before accepting the ratio.
What to adjust when the shadow doesn't respond
If lowering the fill doesn't darken the shadow, the light brightening it isn't coming from your fill: it's coming from a wall, the ceiling or bounce off the floor. Turn the fill off completely and see what's left; that is your real starting point. For complete lighting setups, see the guide to studio lighting, the article Rembrandt, butterfly and side lighting: basic setups and the step-by-step on fill flash outdoors.