Catchlight
A catchlight is the specular reflection of the light source in a subject's eyes in a portrait, giving the gaze life and depth.
Also known as: eye light, highlight in the eyes
A catchlight is the specular reflection of the light source that appears in the subject's eyes in a portrait. Its presence gives life and depth to the gaze; without it, the face looks flat and the whole portrait loses energy. The shape and position of the catchlight give away the source: a large rectangle is a window, a small hard circle is direct flash.
The catchlight is a mirror of your lighting setup. If it doesn't appear, the source is too high or too far to the side.
How do I get it in practice?
With window light, seat the subject a meter from the glass, turned about 45 degrees toward it, and ask them to look slightly toward the window. With an 85 mm on full frame at f/2, 1/160 s and ISO 400 you have plenty of exposure on a bright day and a rectangular catchlight that fills a good part of the iris.
In the studio, position matters more than power. The source has to be within the angle the eye reflects, and that angle is narrow: above roughly 45 degrees of height, the reflection falls outside the iris or the upper eyelid hides it.
Source and distance: 1.5 m window, at 1 m; Reflection shape: Large, soft rectangle; Typical height: At eye level; Feel: Natural, editorial
Source and distance: 90 cm octabox, at 1.2 m; Reflection shape: Large circle, clean edge; Typical height: 30-45° above the eyes; Feel: Classic portrait
Source and distance: 55 cm beauty dish, at 1 m; Reflection shape: Circle with an inner ring; Typical height: 45°; Feel: Beauty, fashion
Source and distance: Ring light, at 0.8 m; Reflection shape: Full ring around the pupil; Typical height: On the lens axis; Feel: Contemporary, obvious
Source and distance: Direct hot-shoe flash; Reflection shape: Small, hard, centered dot; Typical height: On the lens axis; Feel: Documentary, direct
Source and distance: Silver reflector 60 cm below; Reflection shape: Band in the lower part of the iris; Typical height: Under the chin; Feel: Fill, open gaze
What size should it be?
The larger the source relative to the subject, the larger and softer the reflection comes out, and the relative size depends on both the dimensions and the distance. A meter-and-a-half window at one meter is enormous for a face; that same window at five meters behaves like a small source and returns a hard dot.
As a practical reference, a catchlight that fills between a quarter and a third of the iris reads as natural in a studio portrait. Larger starts to look like a cosmetics ad; smaller returns the gaze of an ID photo taken with flash.
What if the catchlight doesn't appear?
Lower the source. It's the correction that solves most cases: a softbox placed almost overhead lights the face well and leaves the eyes dull, because its reflection sits above the iris.
If you can't move it, add a white reflector below, about 60 cm away and tilted slightly upward. It raises the fill and returns a low catchlight that opens up the gaze. The full logic of source, size and distance is in hard light vs. soft light and in lighting setups.
Common mistakes
Two catchlights of the same size. When the main light and the fill are at the same height, each eye carries two identical reflections and the gaze looks artificial. Lower the fill or move it farther away.
Removing it when retouching. The dark-circle cleanup brush easily takes the reflection with it. Work on a separate layer and check it at 100%.
Painting a fake one. A catchlight added in editing has to match the light in the photo in position, shape and hardness; otherwise the viewer's eye detects it even without knowing why.
Photographing people in glasses without moving the source. The same reflection you want in the eye shows up as a white blotch on the lens. Raise the source a few centimeters or tilt the temples downward.
Opening the aperture too wide up close. At f/1.4 and 60 cm away, the depth of field doesn't cover both eyes, and a sharp catchlight in an out-of-focus eye doesn't save the shot.
Window light is the most accessible source for getting it. See the guide to contemporary portrait photography, the one on basic mastery of natural light and the article window-light portrait: a simple setup.