Rembrandt, butterfly and side lighting
Portrait lighting patterns (Rembrandt, butterfly, side) are defined by where the main light sits relative to the subject's face.
Also known as: portrait lighting patterns, lighting setups, split lighting
Portrait lighting patterns (Rembrandt, butterfly, side) are defined by the position of the main light relative to the subject's face. In Rembrandt lighting, the source is at 45° and slightly above, creating a small triangle of light under the eye on the shadow side: dramatic and classic. In butterfly lighting, the source is directly in front of the subject and above, creating a symmetrical shadow under the nose: flattering and used in beauty. In side lighting, the source is at 90°, lighting half the face and leaving the other half in total shadow: high contrast and character.
The nose is the indicator: the shadow it casts tells you exactly where the main light is.
Where exactly do I place the light?
Two angles define the pattern: how far the light moves off the camera axis horizontally, and how far it rises above eye level. You adjust by looking at the nose, not the light meter.
Pattern: Butterfly; Horizontal angle: 0°, on the camera axis; Height above the eyes: 40 – 50°; Signature on the face: Symmetrical shadow under the nose; When you choose it: Beauty, smooth skin, fashion
Pattern: Loop; Horizontal angle: 30 – 35°; Height above the eyes: 30 – 40°; Signature on the face: Diagonal shadow that doesn't touch the cheek; When you choose it: General portrait, the safe option
Pattern: Rembrandt; Horizontal angle: 45°; Height above the eyes: 40 – 45°; Signature on the face: Triangle of light under the eye in shadow; When you choose it: Character, classic portrait
Pattern: Side; Horizontal angle: 90°; Height above the eyes: At eye level; Signature on the face: Half the face lit, half in shadow; When you choose it: Texture, black and white, drama
The Rembrandt triangle has an operational definition: it should be about as wide as the eye and no longer than the nose. If it spills toward the jaw, the light is too low; if it disappears, it is too wide or too high.
What settings do I use in the studio and with window light?
With studio flash and a modifier of about 90 cm at a meter and a half from the subject, f/8, 1/160 s, ISO 100 is the starting point on full frame, and flash power is what you move until the histogram lands where you want. Keep the shutter speed below your camera's sync speed (usually 1/160 s or 1/200 s) or a black band will appear.
With window light on an overcast day, at a meter from the glass, f/2.8, 1/125 s, ISO 400 exposes the face well. The window is the source and you move the subject: turning them 45° to the glass gives Rembrandt, putting them in profile gives side, and seating them facing forward under a high window gives butterfly.
The inverse-square law governs the rest: doubling the distance from the light to the subject costs you 2 stops, and the falloff between the face and the background softens. A light very close gives a quick transition into shadow; moved back, the background is lit almost the same as the face.
Common mistakes
Raising the light too much. Past 50° of elevation, the eyes fall into dark sockets and the catchlight disappears. Lower it until you see the reflection in the iris: that spot is what makes the gaze alive.
Confusing contrast with no fill. A side light without fill light leaves half the face in pure black without detail, which is an exposure error disguised as style. A white reflector at a meter on the dark side recovers much of the detail and keeps the drama.
Applying butterfly to any face. It flatters prominent cheekbones and punishes dark circles and long noses, whose shadow stretches to the lip. When in doubt, start with loop at 30° and move from there.
To set them up step by step, see Rembrandt, butterfly and side light: basic patterns, the guide to studio lighting and the one on mastering natural light basics.