Overexposure and underexposure
An overexposed photo got more light than needed and looks too bright; an underexposed photo got less light than needed and looks too dark.
Also known as: overexposed vs. underexposed, too bright vs. too dark
An overexposed photo received more light than needed and looks too bright; an underexposed photo received less light than needed and looks too dark. In mild degrees, both can be corrected in editing without much loss of quality, especially if you shoot RAW.
Data piled against a wall of the histogram is detail that no longer exists in the file.
The real problem appears when the over- or underexposure is so extreme that it produces clipping: totally white or black areas with no detail to recover, not even in RAW. A mild overexposure with room for recovery (the ETTR technique) can even be desirable; an overexposure with clipping in important areas has no fix.
How do I know a photo is badly exposed before I leave?
The rear screen lies: in full sun it looks dark and at night it looks bright, so judging by it leads you to underexpose by day and overexpose by night. Look at the histogram and turn on the highlight warning (the "blinkies"). If the mass of the histogram touches the right wall, there is white without detail; if it touches the left, there is black without detail.
A quick check without a screen: in full midday sun, the correct exposure is around f/16, 1/100 s, ISO 100 (the sunny 16 rule: shutter speed ≈ 1/ISO at f/16). Its equivalents are f/11 and 1/200 s, or f/8 and 1/400 s. If your camera reads two stops above that in full sun, it is not metering the scene you think it is.
How much can be recovered from a badly exposed photo?
In a 14-bit RAW, lifting 1 stop of underexposure is transparent; at 2 stops, color noise starts to show in the shadows; at 3 stops, banding and greenish or magenta blotches appear in the dark areas. The exact figure depends on the sensor and the ISO you shot at, and nobody publishes a reliable table that works for all cameras.
Highlights are less forgiving: a white clipped in all three color channels contains no information, and no slider invents it. That is why, when in doubt, you protect the highlights and lift the shadows, not the other way around.
What exposure compensation do I apply in each scene?
The meter averages the scene to a middle gray, so it always fails in the same direction with very bright or very dark scenes. These values are starting points in matrix metering; confirm with the histogram.
Scene: Snow or beach in full sun; What the meter does: Underexposes: averages the white to gray; Compensation: +1 to +2 EV; Result: White snow, not dirty gray
Scene: Backlit portrait; What the meter does: Underexposes the face; Compensation: +1 to +2 EV; Result: Face with detail, background blown out
Scene: Concert or black background; What the meter does: Overexposes: averages the black to gray; Compensation: −1 to −2 EV; Result: Blacks that are black, focus on the subject
Scene: Sky with bright clouds; What the meter does: Overexposes the clouds; Compensation: −0.7 EV; Result: Texture in the clouds
Scene: White dress indoors; What the meter does: Underexposes the fabric; Compensation: +0.7 to +1 EV; Result: White with visible seams
Every correction costs something: +1 EV on a backlit scene means accepting a blown-out background, and −2 EV at a concert means accepting that the dimmer parts of the subject come out darker.
Common mistakes
Correcting exposure with ISO in manual mode. ISO does not change the light that comes in: it amplifies the signal afterward. If the photo is underexposed because the shutter speed is too fast, raising the ISO hides the symptom and adds noise. Open the aperture or lengthen the exposure first.
Looking only at the luminance histogram. A saturated blue sky can clip the blue channel while the overall histogram looks healthy. Check all three RGB channels when the scene has a dominant color.
Relying on recovery as a plan. "I'll fix it in the raw converter" works with half a stop, not with three. Adjust in camera and use the equivalent exposure calculator to change apertures without altering brightness.
To read the histogram while you shoot, see the guide to reading the histogram and the article on common exposure mistakes and how to avoid them.